Home > gear talk > Summitar 50mm f2 and Leica M9

Summitar 50mm f2 and Leica M9

November 17, 2011 Leave a comment Go to comments

Leica M9 and Summitar 50mm f2 (1949)

Leica M9 and Summitar 50mm f2 (1949)

The beauty of any camera system capable of utilizing an M-mount lens is that you have a nearly endless selection of glass from which to experiment with and explore.  And while you can get M-Mount adapters to use Rangefinder glass on cameras like the Sony NEX-5, or Olympus E-P3, the only way to do it right is to use a full frame camera like the Leica M9.  This is particularly important when one is using one of the “character” lenses.  What I mean by “character” is, in a nutshell, sub-par optical performance.

Modern lens designs such as Lecia’s Aspherical Summilux series are as optically perfect as has ever been achieved.  The images they produce have a richness and pop that is hard to explain, it really must be seen to be understood.  But for all that perfection, there are more than just a few photographers out there that prefer a somewhat more organic experience.  I liken it to those that prefer the crackle, hiss, and pop of vinyl to the crystal clear digital perfection of a compact disk or MP3.

One of the more famous of character lenses is the Summitar 50mm f2.  It is a L39 screw mount collapsable lens design, which is great for saving space in a camera bag.  To use it on the M9 one must get an L to M mount adapter, and for those of you that were wondering, it does safely collapse on the M9.

The basic design dates back to 1939 and it was produced until 1953.  Lenses manufactured after WWII were coated, and the original 10-bladed diaphragm was changed to a 6-bladeed version in 1950.   The version I own is from 1949, which places it right in the sweet spot so it retains the 10-bladed aperture, yet is coated.  The aperture control does not have any click-stops, and the focusing tab has an infinity lock.

Most of the images I will show here weer taken wide open, but I have included one sample image taken wide open and f2, as well as f8, just to give you an idea of how the performance of this lenses changes as you stop it down.  Please note: most of these images have at least a little adjustment to them in LightRoom 3, normally just a quick “Direct Positive” filter application.

Minimum focus distance, F2

Minimum focus distance, F2

Infinity focus distance, f2

Infinity focus distance, f2


f2

f2 - Even wide open, notice the razor sharp center. But it aslo retains that wonderful swirly bokeh that people have come to prize this lens for.

Minimum focus distance, f2, shooting into the sun to get some flare going

Minimum focus distance, f2, shooting into the sun to get some flare going

f2, notice the soft corners

f2, notice the soft corners

f8, notice how much sharper the corners are

f8, notice how much sharper the corners are

The two photos above show just how easy it use to use this lens as a character lens one minute, then as a very respectably sharp normal lems the next.  I apologize for the slight difference in framing, these were all shot hand held.

This image demonstrates what a wonderful combination this lens is with the M9.

This image demonstrates what a wonderful combination this lens is with the M9.

The lower overall contrast of the Summitar compliments the relatively high dynamic range of the M9 sensor to allow one to shoot in challenging light conditions with relative impunity.  Shadow detail is retained, and highlights are well under control.  Note: I did apply some in-camera exposure compensation on this image, but even so, the range of lighting would have sent one of my Cosina Voigtlander lenses to its knees with its high contrast imaging.

Stopped down to f2.8

Stopped down to f2.8

Stopping this down to f2.8 all but eliminates the characteristic swirley bokeh, but it still retains a pleasing 3D rendering.

f2

f2.8

Selfy at f2

Selfy at f2

f2

f2

minimum focus distance f2

minimum focus distance f2.8

f2

f2

f2.8

f3.5

f2

f2

f3.5

f3.5

f2

f2

f2.8

f2.8

f8

f8

f2

f2

So there you have it.

I do have to say that this lens has exceeded my expectations, particularly since I was able to find one in near pristine condition for less than $400.  It is nowhere near as sharp as most modern lenses.  The Cosina Voigtlander 50mm f1.5 Nokton and 50mm f2.5 color skopar blow it out of the water in the sharpness department.  But what it lacks in edge to edge sharpness, it mor than makes up for in character.

I like it so much in fact that on my upcoming trip to Kyoto, the Summitar will be the only 50mm lens that I will take with me.  I’ll be leave the 50mm Summilux pre-Asph at home in favor of it’s much older and slightly slower sibling.  I’m looking forward to taking advantage of the sharp center and swirley edge bokeh for some fall color shots.

I’ve been to Kyoto more times than I can count, but each time I go I bring a different set of gear to shoot with, and I think the Summitar/M9 combo will fit the bill nicely.  To round out my M9 kit I will likely be taking a CV 28mm f1.9 and Leica 90mm f4.  For extreme low-light work I will bring along the the FUJI X100 as it very decidedly blows thew doors off the M9 in the high ISO department.  It also takes care of the 35mm field of view if I happen to need it.

So if you are in Kyoto between 23-28 August, you just may run into me there.  I’ll be easy to find, just look for the guy with the smile on his face. :)

About these ads
Categories: gear talk Tags: , , , , , , , ,
  1. Marco
    November 22, 2011 at 4:11 pm

    Jeff,
    great to see you post some gear & photo stuff again! :-)

    Are you really planning your Kyoto trip that much into the future (August 23-28), or is this a typo? Anyway, I wish I could accompany you with my Rolleiflex Automat and X100 :-)

  2. 2yen
    November 22, 2011 at 10:25 pm

    Oops, yes, that was a typo. I will be there from 23-28 NOVEMBER. :)
    I would love to have you join me for some photo walking!

  3. Kryn
    December 19, 2011 at 12:27 pm

    ha, I already DID join you :p

    gear wise, you really gonna get rid of the M9? Really???
    Well, I have to say, I got myself an X100 fror 30% cheaper than kyoto (who would ever had though China to be cheaper than Japan for import products – dont ask, fuji is considered import even if its made in china…). I absolutely love that X100! and I have the sam eissue with the exp comp dial…
    I wrote Fuji an email (which Im sur ethey will ignore), to say they shoulkd make an X100 dereivative that has an M-mount… That’d be a killer cam!

    Don’t worry Jeff, I still love teh Pson too ;)

  4. Marco
    December 19, 2011 at 2:05 pm

    Frustrating thing is that the 50% cheaper X10 – which I have been using for the past 3 weeks, fixes most of the issues that we have with our X100.

    If the X10 only had the APS-C sensor and the hybrid – I would even go for the electronic – viewfinder, then it would be a perfect package!

    That said, the X10′s sensor does extremely well in dynamic range, color and high ISO!

  5. Andrew
    August 28, 2013 at 12:03 am

    Love the shot of the battleship Mikasa. I toured her last year and had a great discussion with the curator. I’ve been fascinated by the story of that ship and the battle of Tsushima since I read about at age 8, 38-years-ago. It is one of my very favorite things in Japan.

    The Simmitar is quite nice too, just ordered a fully serviced one from Sherry Krauter to use on my Monochrom.

  6. May 15, 2014 at 2:45 pm

    Geat, great! Beautiful photos!

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 437 other followers

%d bloggers like this: